Apr 11, 2020 | Featured Poems

The Post-Modern Problem with Trolleys and Footbridges

 

 

For Doctor Williams

so much depended

         on a red barrow,

         rain-glazed and split with

         precision. Also

         adjacent chickens.

 

A runaway train,                                                                                                                 A runaway train,

         five people tied to                                                                                                              five people tied to

a railway track, one                                                                                                           a railway track, one

person a spur line,                                                                                                             fat man leaning over

a point switch saves five,                                                                                                 a footbridge, push him,

kills one.                                                                                                                              save five.

 

Can this be

the architecture

of a moral choice?

Does so much depend

on so few details?

Would a faulty switch,

 

an imposed diet,

make a difference

to a moral life?

But what colours were

the point switch, the fat

man’s clothes, the bridge paint?

 


 

The Trolley and Footbridge problems were developed by Philippa Foot and Judith Jarvis Thomson, respectively, to illustrate moral choices.  Certain phrases are taken or adapted from by William Carlos Williams’ ‘The Red Wheelbarrow’..

More news

Three poems in new anthology

Three poems in new anthology

I am thrilled to announce that three new poems - "Distant Discourse", "Any Way the Wind Blows" and "Amniocentesis" - appear in a new anthololgy of Australian formal verse published by Bonfire Books. You can find it here.

read more
Reciting on DMQ Virtual Salon

Reciting on DMQ Virtual Salon

Here is a link to video of me reciting poems from A Fickle Pendulum - link.  The various readings are in year and month order.  I read in June, 2022.

read more
Three Poems in ScienceWriteNow

Three Poems in ScienceWriteNow

Three of my poems are now available in Edition 6 of Science Write Now on the theme of Natural History and Historians. To quote from their website: "Science Write Now is a network of people and resources that supports creative writing about science. We believe that...

read more